Can BHG disclose the drop rate percentages on artifact lines?

[LuSt]

@Harlems369th @TheWise

A question on many players minds now that 12.20 has pushed through is… how likely are we to get a natural 3 lined artifact with the same troop name?

Basic probability of 3 categories: weapon, armor, war equipment, with weapons and armor having 120 possibilities (troop type and 3 separate percentage rates) while war equipment has 90 possibilities of the same standard. Tells us that there is a 1 in 5000 chance of getting a natural 3 liner or more while crafting in a war hall pool.

Unfortunately that is only if the drop rates on percentages are equal, but it’s safe to assume they are not based on player data.

Considering we now have massive amounts of crafting ahead of us, can BHG share their drop rates for 1%, 3%, and 6% on war hall artifacts and 3%, 6%, 9% on main hall artifacts?

I’m not sure why it has been so secretive over the years or even if that was intentional. The only real information we’ve been given in regards to these drop rates is during crafting events by saying “5x’s the chance of getting 6% lines”, but the question is… 5 times what?

I also don’t see the harm in sharing those rates just so players could have a better idea of how likely it will be to get natural 3 liners or more.

Is this something you could please share with the players? Not looking to stir up trouble, I’m just genuinely curious on what to anticipate.

 

[Romeo Jellybean]

Hi Harlem
I imagine the two comments "low drop rate" and "floodgates wide" are causing some confusion - so are you able to give us an idea of what the odds of "low drop rate" actually are??
It might help soothe some ruffled feathers. (or not)

This player tried already but maybe you have better luck

 

[Funny]

I think in “5x’s the chance of getting 6% lines” active, it has 50% to get 1%, 25% to get 3%, 25% to get 6%

 

[LuSt]

Yea that’s one theory but I expect BHG to be a bit more complex than that

 

[Harlems369th]

@Harlems369th @TheWise

A question on many players minds now that 12.20 has pushed through is… how likely are we to get a natural 3 lined artifact with the same troop name?

Basic probability of 3 categories: weapon, armor, war equipment, with weapons and armor having 120 possibilities (troop type and 3 separate percentage rates) while war equipment has 90 possibilities of the same standard. Tells us that there is a 1 in 5000 chance of getting a natural 3 liner or more while crafting in a war hall pool.

Unfortunately that is only if the drop rates on percentages are equal, but it’s safe to assume they are not based on player data.

Considering we now have massive amounts of crafting ahead of us, can BHG share their drop rates for 1%, 3%, and 6% on war hall artifacts and 3%, 6%, 9% on main hall artifacts?

I’m not sure why it has been so secretive over the years or even if that was intentional. The only real information we’ve been given in regards to these drop rates is during crafting events by saying “5x’s the chance of getting 6% lines”, but the question is… 5 times what?

I also don’t see the harm in sharing those rates just so players could have a better idea of how likely it will be to get natural 3 liners or more.

Is this something you could please share with the players? Not looking to stir up trouble, I’m just genuinely curious on what to anticipate.

No plans to do so at this time, if it isn't shared in-game we don't discuss it. Maybe one day!

 

[LuSt]

No plans to do so at this time, if it isn't shared in-game we don't discuss it. Maybe one day!

Thank you for the response.

I still don’t understand why this is treated like the super secret Coca-Cola recipe… it’s just drop rates like you share about chests.

Would you mind explaining what potential harm could come from sharing this information? I really just can’t come up with any way it would be negative or exploited?

 

[Joe]

if it is the same as with troop movement speed then the devs themselves probably don't even know the %