Shahib Idris - Swedish Army - Leaderboard Cheat

[Eddie F1]

Woke up to the usual attack, lost a medal and a lot of resources but it was the 5 star I was curious about, 5 starring an Industrial base is very difficult, especially with the army this character arrived with - so I watched the replay a few times hoping to see how it's done.

But no, 6 demolitions on the TC, a bit of skirmishing and he quits after 30 seconds, but took more loot than was available (and I'm sure a lot more trade goods than shown) and a 5 star result. Same replay every time.

Shahib Idris - you are a cheat and an imbecile attacking forum members and hoping to get away with it. Swedish Army alliance motto is 'Fair Play' - you are a joke allowing your top player to cheat their way to the top. Nike, leader of Swedish Army, What are you going to do about it?







So here's an ultimatum - this cheat is removed from the game and leaderboard by the weekend or I quit. Take your pick, cheat or player.

Did Ben Johnson receive a slap on the wrist and a 1 race ban for cheating at the 1988 Olympics? Or Lance Armstrong have his bicycle taken away for a day? No they were deleted from the record books.

BHG/Nexon, you need to get a grip on the widespread cheating or this game instead of being a 'Game of War' will be just a 'Game of Cheats' , you are fast losing all credibility. All the bugs and glitches are just about tolerable and can be worked around, but we can never compete with cheats - what's the point of trying.

All the other forum posters who have quit playing before me, Redgar, Gambrinius, Aussie Guy, BambooCoC back to Booquia, WhatWhat, Andy - we might be the noisy few around here, but for each one us that quit, there are probably 100's or 1000's of the silent majority who quit too. And the cheats just carry on and they don't pay your wages.

 

[dbukalski]

U can add to me to the list of quit players do to cheating, pointless alliance wars, and cheating in alliance wars

Now im just hanging around on forum and game chat while i keep eye open to next game to play

Alliance wars was my cutoff point for them to get control of their game. Meaning ban people who cheat. And to roll out a war worth a dam.n

 

[Maurmo]

No Title

I reported these two. Nothing done. Given what I see and frustrating bugs that keep the medal table blank for 2 weeks or more - why should I put real money into the game?

 

[Quovatis]

Great, we have a war with that alliance and player today. I'm sure he'll 5-star our top 2.

 

[polo1967]

I know its part of the game, but I'm not a big fan of the Demolition tactic. The ability to blow up something without stepping foot on a base? The guerilla, is basically the same thing but at least its more plausible and requires a bit more strategy.

 

[Nathan Win]

Seems like they dont have the capability to deal with cheating. They might as well give up and sell this game to Supercell.

 

[Guest]

Thanks Eddie! These get seen faster in a PM, but he's been sanctioned.

 

[JuDomines]

What sanction is applied in such case IronAngel?

 

[Guest]

I reported these two. Nothing done. Given what I see and frustrating bugs that keep the medal table blank for 2 weeks or more - why should I put real money into the game?

Where did you report them? I've fixed them today.

 

[Aurelius...]

I'd be curious to hear the response to this as well. What is an appropriate sanction for cheating?

 

[polo1967]

I agree. The response to this question may be a deal breaker for me.

 

[Nathan Win]

Hopefully sanctioned is lifetime ban

 

[ivan.]

Banned is the word we'd like to see used more often. Not a 72 hr sanction etc.

 

[Hunter Killer]

CS is clueless with this new cheat. They keep telling me the number of troops is within the limits and it's possible that they can win. I've pointed out the cheat is probably in the demolition but that information probably stops at that offshore support centre and the developers never hear about them.

In a way, I don't mind getting attacked by cheaters as long as I get crown compensation for it. But right now CS is playing it dumb and not doing anything or compensating. The only people who 5 star me these days are the cheaters so it's obvious for me to spot.

And screw that excuse "the replays are not accurate". Yes they are not, I see some small differences in my attack replays. BUT the differences are small e.g. order of building destroyed or number of surviving troops, or maybe missing the last 1% or 2% destruction. Here, when the battle stops, the guy didn't even get one star. And where he deploys on my base, I know he can never get the quick victory star.

Mentally, I have already quit. This game has no future. We are still hanging around here until the next coc clone comes out. I do max 10 battles a day to keep my upgrades going just in case they have a stroke of genius and hire some good developers/game designers/security experts. But I'm pretty much done with this game already.

The "it's a new game, give it some time" doesn't work anymore. It's been a whole year. There are structural and design issues in this app that won't be tackled anytime soon if ever.

 

[Nathan Win]

I'm curious as to why they haven't try to hire better game designer/developers

 

[leoelephant]

Hunter, after at least 2000+ words analysis written to a cs guy I did yesterday, to analyse why this is not discrepancy between log and actual, I finally got this guy understood the issue and one thing I am sure is the analysis has been sent to development team. And also from the feedback, bhg already recognise this issue as a game level issue and they need to find a way to prevent it and fix the game machinism defect as a whole. He apologise that he will not immediately provide solution for mr reported seven cases but they are working to get solution to fix this issue as a whole.

I am semi-ok with what he said.

 

[Eddie F1]

100% agree.

You paid me a visit 3 days ago, but I was out. It's interesting how 2 heavy tanks, 6 artillery, 2 trucks, etc fair against me - 3 stars - this is what I expect, or 2 star snipes on the the TC as it's just sat there on the outside.

5 Starring any IA base is borderline impossible with the current troop balance, so when somebody turns up and 5 stars you with a few troops, it attracts attention. Cheats are going to have to do better if they try to hide behind 'reasonable' looking tactics.

 

[Eddie F1]

Update: CS haven't said anything other than "can't discuss other players' yada yada, but Shahib Idris doesn't appear to be a member of Swedish Army any more nor on the Leader Board, but I've had a few beers and may have gone blind

 

[Jane Monroe]

I can still see him Eddie, he dropped to 200 medals and is in spot 48 of his Alliance.

 

[leoelephant]

Really, so it is all because iron angle you are looking at this post right, will you please do me a favour to check Bradd in top dominator, he is one of this type cheaters I reported to cs.

Please also investigate him as his alliance is in leaderboard so I always monitor him. I reported his five star cheat a month ago, he is still in top dominator and he is even rising from no 26 to 16.

I do not know how to post pic here, please contact me I will give you the screenshot cheating proof