Cheater! Player with 14 Triplanes. Screenshots Inside!

[Gears]

Nb4powerup

A player from my alliance shared a replay of an attack on alliance chat where according to replay, he was attacked by a player (ÇevikKuvvet from Turk Warriors) with 14 Triplanes and lost the attack.

Is the player cheating?

Screenshot of battle result at the end of the replay.

Battle results screen showing Victory and also the troops used for the attack which include the 14 Triplanes.(I received an error while uploading the 2nd screenshot.)

Use this link instead because Nexon forums upload is failing constantly.
https://ibb.co/m3dZi6


Ignore the British riflemen icon for Korean riflemen, I think it is a bug with the game.

 

[Gears]

Bump. Since no one has replied to my original post.

 

[melheor]

If he only managed 37% destruction with 14 planes then he really sucks at guiding them.

 

[Gears]

If he only managed 37% destruction with 14 planes then he really sucks at guiding them.

Based on the replay, that player also deployed a level 30 Napoleon in the last few seconds and lost.

 

[Nyborjar]

something close to that, (unless there is an option I'm not aware of ...?) I attacked someone, and when I reached his city, no lying, many many canons popped out of it ; but like 10 or more canons !!!! how is that possible ?? considering that a canon is 9 or 10 units big ? how can a portal contain this many units please ? or is it cheat ?
I'll try to get the screenshoot asap

 

[yemen]

Replays are not accurate. The troops deployed / lost list at the end of the replay are accurate to what it showed in that replay, but have no relationship to the actual battle if the replay is wrong. The attack log is considered by Nexon to be the definitive result.

My guess is that something early on happened in the replay that resulted in the loss of many troops, and it did not happen in the actual attack.

Planes are deployed at the exact time and to the exact spot that they were in the actual battle. But they are damaged by the buildings that are there in the replay, even if those buildings were already destroyed in the actual battle. So if the replay shows the army getting murdered early, they wouldn't destroy the towers. Then the planes, that in the real battle are being deployed over destroyed towers and air defenses, die in the replay. But since they didn't die in the real battle, the player keeps sending them out, and the replay faithfully records that. Since the planes it knows about died, it sends out replacements. 14 total deployments of three planes, where the plane survives in each case, becomes 14 deployments of 14 planes, as they die in each pass.

Napoleon is dropped in the replay exactly as he was in the actual battle. Probably to clean up the last few percent in the actual battle, but it looks crazy in the replay with everything still alive.

There is no evidence of cheating here. Just a very buggy replay. It happens in war as well - one of my teammates had a 1 star war victory in our last war, and the replay showed 3, almost 4. It was just inaccurate.

 

[Quovatis]

Unless the log also shows that many planes being deployed, it's just a replay bug. Why they can't figure out how to correct replays after 2+ years is beyond me.

 

[Gears]

There is no evidence of cheating here. Just a very buggy replay. It happens in war as well - one of my teammates had a 1 star war victory in our last war, and the replay showed 3, almost 4. It was just inaccurate.

I have shared link to image (https://ibb.co/m3dZi6) of the battle results screen which shows the troops used and lost in the attack. 14 Planes were deployed and lost. So even the battle results for replay are not accurate when it comes to displaying the number and types of troops used in the attack?

I will still try to confirm the details of defense log with team member and report back.

 

[Quovatis]

Nope, not accurate at all. Only the defense log is accurate. Now, if you have a shot of 14 planes on the field at the same time, that's different.

 

[TinSoldier]

Last I knew, this was a bug that appeared in replays, if the plane was destroyed during the replay, but lived through the moment in the original attack. There were never more than 3 planes attacking your base at a time when I watched the replay. I've passed this instance to the team to investigate.

 

[Gears]

Yes TinSoldier, either this can be pinned to the replay bug as that alliance member has confirmed only 3 Triplanes are shown in his defense log attack or these players are indeed cheating consider the number of reports complaining the same thing on this forums.