War is unbalanced ! Changes are needed

xenokii

New member
Joined
Dec 24, 2023
Messages
9
Hello

I propose a change to war for it feels very one sided. If you’re top 5 fails you loose and it doesn’t matter if you’re 10 to 20. I constantly get attacked and 5 starred by people 1 or even 2 ages higher and it feels I could be absent for every war and it wouldn’t matter.

The changes would be that if someone is 3 ranks below you ( a 9 attacking a 12) then the max stars you can get would only be 3 stars. This would force every player to participate in war and no matter what place in you’re in you’d play a part.
 

MixOnUs

Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2023
Messages
31
The example u mentioned is not a reason why war is unbalanced, but the troop tactics tho. for example you're in iron age and somebody from automation age donates u Ying yi lvl 12. + something else. any iron age/medieval/gunpowder etc. won't do a trick, unless they got betrayal war tactic or much higher player must beat base. In short not the matchmaking is problem, but the troop tactics tho, which cause high difficulty for new players.
 

xenokii

New member
Joined
Dec 24, 2023
Messages
9
The example u mentioned is not a reason why war is unbalanced, but the troop tactics tho. for example you're in iron age and somebody from automation age donates u Ying yi lvl 12. + something else. any iron age/medieval/gunpowder etc. won't do a trick, unless they got betrayal war tactic or much higher player must beat base. In short not the matchmaking is problem, but the troop tactics tho, which cause high difficulty for new players.
I agree that donated troops should match for war ( offensive or defensive) but even if that’s fixed you’ll still have the whole war determined by there top 5
Hello

I propose a change to war for it feels very one sided. If you’re top 5 fails you loose and it doesn’t matter if you’re 10 to 20. I constantly get attacked and 5 starred by people 1 or even 2 ages higher and it feels I could be absent for every war and it wouldn’t matter.

The changes would be that if someone is 3 ranks below you ( a 9 attacking a 12) then the max stars you can get would only be 3 stars. This would force every player to participate in war and no matter what place in you’re in you’d play a part.
i would like to mention that there are alliances who’s roster has bot accounts to lower make match making easier . We fought a team who’s bottom 5 were Bronze Age and everyone one else was 250 or higher. If you are ranked below 10 only one of your attacks matters , if you’re ranked below 15 , it does not matter. If your top 2, maybe even your just your top player gets only 3-5 stars then it’s over . Too many wars where only 2 people out of the top 10 failed horribly and costed us the war. That is unbalanced, that needs to be changed
 

xenokii

New member
Joined
Dec 24, 2023
Messages
9
My current war, their top 5 is 350 plus. We have 2 guys that high. It’s a loss won’t even be close. There bottom 5 all around 150. Our bottom 5 is stronger but in war they play no role
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
264
So your basically saying match making is the problem not the quote unbalanced war . What you describe is simply match making not an imbalance in war. You post should have been labeled Match Making Issue.

Your alliance should recruit pure offense players. Most war I see the bottom 10’are the killers seen level 374 smoke bases 430 and above all the time. Your alliance war weight is your alliance problem causing mismatch. I suggest you study up on war weight, get more wars under your belt and knowledge of match making.

Offense will always have advantages over D. If they made any harder for O players they would be screaming in every forum post.
 
Last edited:

MixOnUs

Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2023
Messages
31
Now. that's accurate, and only unbalanced thing to begin with is overleveled troop tactics on defense, for low level players.
 

TheWise

Big Huge Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 21, 2015
Messages
479
Thank you for your feedback. We announced in our road ahead post here that we're implementing changes to the matchmaking system in a future update. We've made incremental changes recently to improve the experience but there is still more that we'd like to do to overhaul the system. We cant wait to share more information as it becomes available.
 

xenokii

New member
Joined
Dec 24, 2023
Messages
9
Thank you for your feedback. We announced in our road ahead post here that we're implementing changes to the matchmaking system in a future update. We've made incremental changes recently to improve the experience but there is still more that we'd like to do to overhaul the system. We cant wait to share more information as it becomes available.
Yall have done great with the quality of life changes so far, but for war I’m really excited to see what’s being planned out. I think the goal should be to make every players attack matter and maybe even preventing donating troops that people don’t have . One helicopter would prevent any industrial age player and below from participating lol
 
Top