After 5.3 comes 5.4 incl. War Replays right ?

[Spaceboy]

As we are all now digesting the 5.3 update with quite some new features (thanks Nexon), can we come back on the War Replays please ? Any chance to see this in 2017 ?

PS : I forgot to ask about stalemates and sandb...keeping this for my 2018 question.

 

[S_How]

Whats the point of replays, when complex attacks (like war attacks) are so frequently wrong in replays? I think it will probably just lead to even more frustration when a replay shows a 2 star defense but the war board shows 5*. I think it would be cool if they did add a recap screen similar to multiplayer where it showed what troops and tactics were used though! Not trying to put down the idea, I just think in their current state war replays would cause a lot of problems lol.

I do agree with your PS.....I think stalemates are close to being resolved, but sandbagging is awful.

 

[Nb4powerup]

This is something BHG is trying to make happen but we don't have an ETA just yet.

 

[benjieland]

If you do not find a solution at the moment
For that is not banish the teams that continue this practice ?

 

[o0zuel0o]

replay's should be available to everyone in your alliance. Replays roll for war would be for a learning and teaching experience, allowing people to critique your fighting skills. So i vote yes for replay's for both defense and equally important offense available for entire alliance to review. This probably requires a new dashboard similar to the war report even after wars have moved on to allow you to review current and past attacks. I am less concerned with it not showing correct star rewards as long as the combat is the same.

 

[Spaceboy]

nb4 is talking about war replays I think and not about sandbagging

 

[QuébecGlory]

Thanks Nb4, no new development is better than no news. We like to feel like we matter.

 

[Sav Lav]

S_How is 100% exactly correct. There is no point of having World War replays due to the fact that replays don't depict what actually happens in the battles. In other words, replays are not actually replays at all. I've confirmed this over and over with customer service.

I have had hundreds of replays that don't match the attack record. Not only that, but if you go back and rewatch replays, they CHANGE!!! So a "replay" of your attack that depicts a 3 star attack when it was actually a five star attack, you can go rewatch later and it's a completely different replay all together.

So given these facts, S_How is absolutely correct in saying that World War replays (given the myriad of issues with "replays") would only further muddy the waters as to what actually transpired during World War attacks. Yes it's frustrating, lot's of things are frustrating about the game. Card armies in wars are disgusting and forcing people to quit. They're ruining the only fun part of the game unfortunately.

 

[Bobortvogel]

I would still rather see a reply as in raiding that may be off verses the current blindness.

 

[Fetterkey]

Here's a suggestion - what if, even if they can't show a full replay, they enable an "after action report" like with normal battles that shows what troops, tactics, etc. were used? While it wouldn't be as good as having the complete replay available, at least you would know what sorts of units were in play, whether the opponent used troop tactics against you, and so on.

 

[Spaceboy]

I still want to see the attach on my war base in order to improve it. As I cannot copy my warbase as a normal base, I'm completely blind on my base design. Also, would be good to review alliance members' attacks to give them advice.
Of course, if the replay is not accurate, then it will hurt more than having nothing.

 

[S_How]

I think this is a great idea

 

[Wendy]

spit on me! I don't want war replays! i always thought it was made on purpose to make you try different layouts
the only reason i would like war replays would be to know if enemy used troop cards or not. i feel there are several more important things to do and fix to make wars better.

 

[Manifesto]

From what I can imagine about other alliances, I think everyone in an alliance talks amongst themselves very well and plan attacks in meticulous detail. As long as your offense is solid and you have a good base you can expect to do well. Unless the opponent has 100% 5 star attacks, you should just concentrate on attacking to the best of your ability and forget about seeing how your enemy attacked you, at least for now.
In other words, just do what you can and forget the rest.

 

[Glacier]

Why implement more bugs? Why not fix whats already broken first? Can BHG learn to crawl before walking? They seem to be trying to run yet they can't even get out of the crib to even crawl, js!

 

[Kam1983]

There are lots of existing bugs and issues, but WW replays are must. It s not really rocket science and I don't understand why hasn't been implemented yet.

 

[Bull TBE]

I don't get how being able to replay war attacks and especially allow new players how to learn the ropes is wrong. I love this game and it keeps getting better... I am the leader of a very active allliance a lot of players get frustrated and give up. I think if they could learn from advanced players may really help with attrition