Leader of “Indonesia solid” alliance - Irwin is a cheater

[kgaskell01]

take a look... The user “Irwin” is the leader of one of the top Alliances “Indonesia Solid”. one star becomes 5, 200 oil becomes 6000+. Wonder how many alliance wars were stolen victories?

wonder how many other people he cheated?

 

[kgaskell01]

User’s name is actually “Irwan”

 

[LordStark263AC]

Must be a Turk living in Indonesia....

 

[paminjo]

this happens often, replay is not good but report is.. it depends on your mobile phone, android or iphone, replays are not the same.. if he attacked you with android, replay is good only if you watch it on adroid..

 

[kgaskell01]

Really Paminjo? The replay is NOT even close and does not even use the full battle time. Your argument is that he defeated my entire base in 1:25 and the replay is bad. Without even knowing what you are talking about, you defend a cheater. So NO, Irwan is a cheater and I believe that BHG / NEXON needs to do something about it other than give me the 300 crowns. He is still the active leader of “Indonesia Solid” alliance. Cheating other paying players and probably cheating Alliances.

 

[yemen]

Some attacks are clearly and obviously cheats. They beat bases like yours with no tactics, their plane count goes astronomical (in the replay they die many times), and use no mercenaries. Several people in our alliance near your level (230+) have been hit for 4-5 stars by players using only planes and barracks troops. This is with blessings and generals up, fully loaded traps. Replay shows no stars and planes continuing to come out multiple times after dying. They use no tactics, blessings, generals, or mercenaries.

This particular set of screenshots look like a classic replay error to me. Something along the lines of a stray silo shot to a different place, or a town center FH that got away in the replay, or a forest spawn difference that results in his mercs dying fast. If cheating, he is somewhat incompetent compared to the replays I have seen, as he would have to rebuild his mercenaries and tactics.

The replay not using the full battle time is consistent with replay errors too. Some difference that results in your silo surviving past a sabotage means all his troops die fast. Whereas with the silo dead in his battle, it would have taken more time to finish clearing the whole base.

There is no proof either way, but your differences are all within the realm of possibility for screwed up replays. Skillfully handled, it is plausible that that mix of troops, mercenaries and tactics could 5 star a 235 base.

 

[Mcnasty]

Replay bug bud. Did you read what he said before you commented? My last war I watched a replay of me getting smashed. My replay showed 100% 5 stars on iOS. I watched the same replay on my buddies account on android and the replay showed 64% and 1 star. With the troops used I don’t see why they couldn’t 5 star you.

 

[kgaskell01]

Sorry, but not buying the replay bug on this. 1:25 to destroy my whole base with resources he deployed? I get hit enough and I know a cheater when I see one. The guys with the unlimited resources (I.e.more than 5 planes) are one kind of cheater. This is another, the type that intercept the results locally before reporting back to the servers.

 

[Mcnasty]

Where does it say 1:25

 

[kgaskell01]

Did no say it in the original post, but brought it on several of my clarifications/ responses. The replay give the the battle a time of 1:25 before it bounces to battle result page.

 

[kgaskell01]

No Title

Since I was asked, here is a screen print showing the beginning of the battle - 2 seconds in. Total battle time was 1:25. Irwan also ended the battle with resources, albeit depleted (3 People’s riflemen, a solo field howitzer and 2 Tank Destroyers) still on the battlefield. The battle ending page actually shows that all of his resources were destroyed. So I really disputed e that this is a “replay” bug issue. I find it hard to believe that his superior game play enabled him to defeat my base in only 1:25 This user Irwan is a cheater and should be dealt with by the game development team, but is still there, probably cheating away against legitimate PAYING users like me in regular battle and Alliance wars.

 

[Mcnasty]

You’re going by the replay which we’ve stated is wrong. This you still have buildings left at the end?
If the replay itself is wrong that would also mean the timer is wrong

 

[kgaskell01]

I see at least one cheater a week. Not buying the replay bug. Not in this case.

 

[kgaskell01]

Interesting Mcnasty, that when it happened to you, the attack log was wrong, but the replays were right. Direct from your posting log:

“I’ve noticed the past few days that the attack log is wrong but replays are right. I got attacked twice, the first time they got 3 stars. The replay...”

i see about one cheater a week. This guy is definitely a cheater and needs to be treated as such.

 

[Mcnasty]

Yes but I also posted one where I was attacked in war and 5 starred. On my iOS the replay was right, 5 stars 100% but when I watched the same replay on one of my members android it showed 1 star 64% so there are problems both ways. That post was about how the tactics used was wrong on the attack log not that they were cheating. The replay would show 6 demos used but attack log would show only 1

 

[Manifesto]

Another new, or possibly 'old', hack.
I was attacked by one armoured car last night. The log showed 1 car and the replay consistently showed 1 car.
He attacked in the first few secs, got killed and for the remaining time nothing happened. The end report showed no rss but the log showed a 5star win with all rss (except oil thankfully).
The 5star hack was further confirmed by me receiving a 15hr peace treaty. Clearly, if it wasn't recorded as a 5star victory I wouldn't have received the PT.
CS thanked me for reporting this ''in game violation'' and gave me 300 crowns for my losses.
The alliance is called Kizil Elma, just happens to be Turkish for Red Apple. Oh, he also had 4 barracks.

PS: maybe Nexon are buffing the raiders?

 

[kgaskell01]

Thread can be closed. Cheater was removed from the game via a different thread.