No stars - no loot

[Jakob_888]

Hi Nexon

I recommend you change the way you get loot in multiplayer.

I think you odd only to get loot when you get minimum one star in battle.
This way you will get loot when "you deserve" it - when you win the battle! If you loose, you deserve nothing
We will end these weird "raider" armies with only one purpose - targeting oil wells, mills and markets - and loosing deliberately without giving away peace trieties. We will also end the weird bases with the town center exposed and all recourses protected by walls.
It messes up the real intent of this great game. I hope you reconsider and change this aspect.
There are really no reason why it shouldnt be like this. We will thereby get peace trieties every time your base is attacked and defeated. Like you odd to.

Thank you.

 

[QuébecGlory]

Raider attacks are part of the game. I see no problem with that. My opinion. Above 2600 medals, it almost never happens. People who raid, get raided. People who play like in ww and protect their TC, face full attacks. Let's not fix what's not broken, there's enough on BHG's plate!

 

[Quovatis]

I think if an attacker deploys a full army, you should get a peace treaty whether you defended or not. Right now you are punished for defending, as you are exposed to another attack and potentially lose 2x the resources. Clash refined how they did things and ended exposed tcs. Domi should look at their system

 

[JuDomines]

Remove raider from the game. This unit has nothing to do in a strategy game.

 

[Mebbwebb]

What a short sighted comment. Their is always a reason a raiding unit will exist in a strategy game.

 

[QuébecGlory]

No stars no loot only benefits maxed AA players. Even a maxed IA gets trashed by GA players. Raiders are here to stay, they're part of the strategy.

 

[JuDomines]

Yes it's extreme. But you'd better used to that, I will not stop. I definitely think using raiders attack is for noobs.

 

[Jakob_888]

I dont mind if you raid for loot or go for all 5 stars. I dont like you can get the loot for no real effort.
The loot should only get "paid" to you if you get a star.

 

[Blacknife686]

I think you should get peace treaties for damage done to specific buildings. For example if a raider army takes down a resource building like a refinery or market, the defending player should be given a 30 minute treaty per building destroyed. That means Industrial or Global players can be rewarded up to 6 1/2 hours of treaties, IF the attacker does not receive any stars.

If the attacker DOES get at least 1 star then that can overwrite resource treaties.

 

[Persia]

Unfortunately, your personal opinion doesn't change the fact that it's by far the easiest raiding tactic. Simply medal dropping down and then hitting poorly constructed bases secures millions of loot per half hour, in both gold and food.

 

[Persia]

I think if an attacker deploys a full army, you should get a peace treaty whether you defended or not. Right now you are punished for defending, as you are exposed to another attack and potentially lose 2x the resources. Clash refined how they did things and ended exposed tcs. Domi should look at their system

I agree, I still consider it a relative loss if I get attacked and repulse an entire army, but it manages to take 200k+ of my resources. That just springs up my traps, deploys my alliance troops if I have any, and still leaves me open to get hit by whoever wants the easy cleanup.

 

[JuDomines]

Persia, you're absolutely right and that is the whole of this post. Using raiders require ~0 skills (and also 0 fun), that's why it's the easiest way to accumulate loot. Since I'm not a big fan of such mediocrity (sorry to be harsh, but I can't help myself and have to be sincere), I will support all effort to remove low-skill/high reward practices in this game. Because I love the game when it's complex and not when it's easy, I put raiders attacks in the same category than demolition-on-refinery: garbage.

 

[o0zuel0o]

yeah, I am tired logging in to find I have been attacked 3 or 4 times for 300k + resources each attack because of zero stars. I work too hard to get resources for those 7 mil upgrades to be ram-shacked like this!