Victory without earning any Stars?

[kgaskell01]

I thought you had to earn at least one star for a battle to be declared a victory. The attached shows otherwise...

 

[kgaskell01]

Interesting that the user "DaDa" in the DEFEND window shows as being in the alliance "Pinas Alyansa 1", but when I find the alliance (there is only one matching that name), there is no user named "DaDa" in that alliance.

 

[domi870152]

I can't be defeated by these troops