What's the Worst War Tactic?

[FroggyKilla]

Here's a poll for your opinions on the worst War Tactic. Personally, it's First Aid. It doesn't quite make the cut. I thought the 10% healing boost would literally add 10%. But that would be quite overpowered. I was thinking it would add +1 to the percentage of healing. It's a small fix, but it will make it a better choice in my eyes. But what's more important is your opinion. What's the worst war tactic?

 

[Jo-jo]

Lol. All the British archer spammers voting for First Aid

 

[FroggyKilla]

Wait, my suggested change would support cancer? My apologies, ignore this thread then.

 

[Porcupine]

Froggy, who voted for demolition, and who voted for barrage. I would like to know please

 

[Martine]

Forgetting to use them would have been my vote. Sigh ..

 

[DNations Battles]

Definitely first aid

 

[Mr Suplex]

Its interesting how clearly these polls show where the issues lie in terms of balance. First Aid is horrible. Why bother once you have supply carts?

 

[FroggyKilla]

Guess we have our winner.

 

[astero]

The Barrage tactic doesn't strike me as particularly useful.

 

[FroggyKilla]

Nonsense. In the world of defending troops, I find this useful, especially for countering Colosseum and TC troops.

 

[astero]

For troops I have planes. They shred them up in no time.

 

[FroggyKilla]

I'm assuming the Sabotage vote is a troll vote?

 

[Morality]

The fact that the healing from First Aid is percent based and it's kinda low in its heal makes it bad. But switching it to flat heal would cause too much problems.

 

[Motaz Tarek]

first aid main problem is that it's based on area of usage, it would be much better that healing effect is applie to units who were in usage range even if they get out of usage area afterwards that would be more efficient however, i see that the main problem vs tanks is anti tank guns and healing aid is usless when it comes to that point.
i voted for demolition cuz it needs dmg buff also who would use barrage to take out some defender soldiers (not even horses or tanks)

 

[Aurelius...]

Though I don't really think it's my role to educate outside of our alliance, first aid can be very effective in some circumstances. I'd suggest testing it before discarding it as an option.

(Though I think the peashooter spam comment may be right on.)

 

[FroggyKilla]

Found Protect to be the suitable replacement. It pretty much has a similar effect.

 

[Mr Suplex]

For troops I have planes. They shred them up in no time.

What if the troops you want to kill are in a nest of AA guns and towers?

I used to think barrage sucked, and then I started using it once donated cannons and artillery became commonplace. I now actually think its a good tactic and use it regularly.

 

[Mythic]

Protect will save you more damage than first aid restores.

 

[The Huns]

The only two I use are Protect and Sabotage. Once in a war if I had to go against someone with two bunkers close together so I took a Betrayal.

 

[GailWho]

Omg! Me too! So many times I look down at my tray and see I forgot to put my protect on