Missile Silo + Egyptian Coalition working as intended?

[alexandria]

In war I face 2 global age players, both missile silo level 1.

I have level 4 demolition with 2530 damage + 21% boost from mongol coalitions equaling 3061 damage. Using 3 would equal 9183 damage, more than enough to take out a level 1 silo with 7500 health.

However my first war attack has the opponent with an egyptian coaliton with 31% defensive building health which would give the silo a 9825 health value. Needless to say my 3 demolition did not destroy the silo.

My next attack has a level 1 silo with no egyptian coaliton and is destroyed with 3 demolition.

I was told by customer support that defensive coalitions do not grant an armor bonus to silo but it appears that it does. Is this working as intended?

 

[Mcnasty]

Egyptian coalition will boost the silos hitpoints

 

[alexandria]

It's clear now after testing that the egyptian coalition will boost silos health value. I'm guessing this is working as intended, but it goes against what customer support messaged me. . TinSoldier any clarification?

 

[TinSoldier]

Just spoke to a designer. You are correct - the Egyptian Coalition does boost the health of the Missile Silo. I'll also make sure the team knows on our end.

 

[Quovatis]

There is also library research to add HP

 

[Manifesto]

Just spoke to a designer. You are correct - the Egyptian Coalition does boost the health of the Missile Silo. I'll also make sure the team knows on our end.

Any chance the designers can answer our CS queries, instead of CS personnel?

 

[alexandria]

Level 4 demolition is 2300 + 10% from library (battle tactics, chapter 2) = 2530 damage.
2300 +10% +21% = 2300 + 31% = 3013 damage
3 demolition = 3 * 3013 = 9039

Was the opponent alliance level >= 2 ? Then there are 10% alliance perk.
then the missile silo has 7500 +10% +31% = 10 575 hitpoints

why should the coalition do not work for the missile silo? Maybe the CS told not the truth.

Also, for future calculations you can't use this formula [a%+b%=c%] [2300+c%=x] to find a value. I forget what the rule is called in math but you have to add each percent increase independently to the value you are trying to find. So you would add [2300+a%=n], then add [n+b%=x]

Hope that makes sense!

 

[Dvicious]

nexon/BHG math =/= real world math. I beleive in this game % increases/decreases are applied independently to the base value, then summed. Forget what you learned in class