Troop Tactics in Victory Chest are a joke

nucleo

Approved user
Joined
Sep 12, 2017
Messages
22
As long as resources always remain an option I will have no complaints.
 

Jedi Kurt

Approved user
Joined
Jul 12, 2017
Messages
39
Ive noticed that once you collect them it will automatically adjust to your age it would show GP level but in SH its global
 

yemen

Approved user
Joined
Mar 24, 2017
Messages
680
My new longbowman army in my SH says level 3 (GP) and I am atomic. It was the best of three bad options in the dock today. The other choices were a worse army and a worthless blessing. So no, it is the age it claimed it would be.
 

TinSoldier

New member
Joined
Jun 4, 2017
Messages
1,568
As some have guessed, the strength of the Troop Tactics scale as you move up in Medal ranking.

The rewards for being in the Silver I League seemed to match up for currently being in Enlightenment Age.
 

poop_

Approved user
Joined
Apr 7, 2016
Messages
147
I agree. The choices have gotten worse. If they wanted to add these other options for the dock and daily chest, then they should have just increased the options to 5 and then included the recruits and blessings (then they could observe how few actually picked these).

As for the actual card armies from the daily dock bonus, I am wondering if the level of the army is dependent on the dock. Is someone able to confirm or refute this? It was just a hypothesis I had.

The ads... when I got a raider recruit from watching an ad, I almost choked. Seriously? It was a smack in the face. I just made nexon money and they gave me something that I will NEVER EVER find useful. Recruits are the age that you have upgraded them to, so pretty sure a medieval raider does jack squat.
I didn't mind the trade good shipments or merc contracts or card armies from ads, but I would prefer 3 crowns over much of the junk I am getting now.

The only way a recruit would be good is if it was an Elephant Archer recruit or some valuable troop that you couldn't train in your barracks.

I do believe the reason is that the devs don't play the game like we do so they don't really know what players value. I hope they listen to feedback though and make adjustments.
 

yemen

Approved user
Joined
Mar 24, 2017
Messages
680
For those of us in atomic age, that means they are much less valuable than the resources we could have gotten before. Being able to get a single tank destroyer mercenary with the diamonds or cider I could have gotten from the dock before, is far more valuable. Replace that with a blessing I won't use and two cards 4 ages below mine is a complete waste. And the old baseline options - not super great, but decent - have suddenly been drowned out by a flood of worthless things to choose from.

Even (especially?) people in the top leagues depend on having those diamonds available. And the oil / food / gold option in those leagues is almost without fail better than 1 troop card.

It isn't that we are complaining because we expect better cards at lower leagues; its because the non card options are SO much better than the crappy card options, and that was the default until yesterday. I don't want better cards at lower leagues - as an atomic player, I never want to be presented with cards that are below global age, so give me no cards if it will be worse than that. And make sure the old choices are still available every time.

Oh, and fix the ad rewards so they are primarily crowns with the chance of a larger crown payout again. I never want to see a troop recruit as a reward for anything again ever.
 

melheor

Approved user
Joined
Sep 18, 2017
Messages
289
Could we at least get more than 3 slots for available rewards now that we have so much clutter in play?
 

yemen

Approved user
Joined
Mar 24, 2017
Messages
680
It is based on your league, as TinSoldier confirmed just above. Multiple confirmations that it is not tied to dock level.
 

umpirerob

Approved user
Joined
Apr 7, 2017
Messages
19
I have to agree... "recruit" cards are the most worthless thing ever in this game.
 

poop_

Approved user
Joined
Apr 7, 2016
Messages
147
I always thought they existed to trick people into buying them thinking they were actual card troops...
 

nucleo

Approved user
Joined
Sep 12, 2017
Messages
22
yemen They are making these changes to make people actually want to have a high medal count. There are too many atomic age bases that just hover around 800 medals so they can raid easy bases for lots of loot. By making these troop cards very weak at low medal counts, it makes people actually want to raise your medals.

I am at hovering around 2500 medals and I can say for certain we are not dependent on the diamonds available. I never take diamonds because I get more than enough from my multiplayer battles alone. In the last 2 days since the update I have gotten the option of 16250 oil twice for a total of 32500 oil in a 2 day span. This reward used to be 13000 oil per chest before so they did improve the resource rewards in the update, which were already amazing to begin with. The troop card options I have got I believe were global age level but don't quote me on that so they are far from useless if you are actually at a high medal count and need them for world wars.

Last week I got 13000 oil 5 out of 7 days for a total 65000 oil in a week, and the other 2 days I got 3.25 million food and gold. Definitely worth keeping your medals high and you will reap the rewards if you stop pretending to be weaker than you are by purposefully lowering your medals.
 

poop_

Approved user
Joined
Apr 7, 2016
Messages
147
I just thought of something! Maybe the devs think we can use all those recruits instead of having to wait to retrain after the missile silo kills our army.
 

Tiggo

Approved user
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
136
what leaque were you in with the victory boat? if you were silver or bronze i could understand why the army was so poor? if you in upper leaque the armies should be stronger of course.
 

yemen

Approved user
Joined
Mar 24, 2017
Messages
680
nucleo I am a 158 Atomic, so hanging around 800-1200 isn't really pretending to be weaker than I am. But even if I were stronger the point stands - improve incentives by making the rewards BETTER at high leagues, not by making them WORSE at low leagues.

The diamond shortage I mentioned is felt a lot more by my teammate in dynasty. 4-5 star wins were rare - now it is none with the missile silo. The ones in mid empire are experiencing the same thing, and only one has stayed there - the others have now medal dropped rather than deal with every opponent having a silo.
 
Last edited:

LordJestix

Approved user
Joined
May 12, 2017
Messages
805
i got 3 useless recruit options for my league boat. I want trade goods or diamonds, i dont want recruiting troop options. what a waste of a boat.
 

Phinz

Approved user
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
9
Just want to join in with the negative comments. None of the changes to rewards are usefull. Troop recruits, really? Why even have them in game!? If you want me to speed up things, tjen give me more crowns.

If BHG wants people to go for higher medal count they should just scale the old rewards faster instead of givong lowet medal count plain junk.

-Phinz
 

nucleo

Approved user
Joined
Sep 12, 2017
Messages
22
All these people complaining are people who have purposefully tanked their medals to Silver league in order to exploit the medal system and now they are crying because they are stuck in Silver and there are more incentives to be in higher leagues now. I am at 2500 medals and all the troop tactics offered to me are global age level. Far from useless. People will just have to adjust their medal count strategies because exploiting the system isn't working out for them anymore.
 

nucleo

Approved user
Joined
Sep 12, 2017
Messages
22
Lowest medal counts deserve bad rewards. Why should weak people be rewards for their lack of effort? Half of these people brought their medal counts down purposefully to exploit the system. They made their bed and now they can sleep in it.
 
Top