big thumbs down for WW replay

[Motaz Tarek]

really? after all the requests and efforts u had to put u just added an AI dependant war replay just like the multiplayer one?
a single AI change in the battle events will lead to a whole other battle than the actual one
i wasn't so excited about adding war replays cuz it will be most likely as faulty as the one in multiplayer, insignificant in most cases
why other games like CoC get to have actual record of battles while we don't get the same? they can even watch their WW battle live!!!
that's really so disappointing and i hope the beta is somethings different from the actual release

 

[Kaiser Shag]

I had the same problem, I wanted to see how a guy did make 4 stars and 95% against our top 2, the replay shows that the guy did 76% and died, very helpful ...

 

[SebQuattro]

You're wrong. Supercell also uses 'AI dependent' replays, they are never going to record the actual battles. I've had replays differ in Boom Beach from the actual battle, although it does happen very rarely.

Considering how long we've waited for War Replays, i'm happy with what we've got. They are still useful and good for the social aspect of the game.

 

[capt underpants]

agreed.....

 

[Mountainking]

Traps locations will be correct, troops deployed correct, SH troops correct, Troop cards correct, tactics used correct, I can live with a slightly innacurate replay of a battle reenactment.

 

[KniferX]

Wholeheartedly agree.

 

[Motaz Tarek]

how they got live record of battles then? at least put that option here
and yes it could be useful if it goes as what really happened otherwise this is just as crap as MP replays

 

[Motaz Tarek]

so? all these info i could get from my mates in chat apps, if u really support that type of replays u will be left with faulty info about how the battle goes in many cases, this could even happen by an AI mistake in the beginning of the battle that totally changes it from 4 or 5 stars to 1 or 0 stars

 

[Motaz Tarek]

and sorry guys i asked for long time the MP replay system to give accurate battle record don't be mad if I don't accept that to happen in WW too which is more important than the MP ones (which i actually don't bother to watch anymore)

 

[King Barbs]

I also agree, this is working well in our war. We need to accept that like pvp replays it might not be totally accurate but the basic information about attack position is what really helps with better base design.

 

[Manifesto]

You're absolutely right, Motaz, I think you should quit this game immediately!

 

[Motaz Tarek]

nah not a reason to quit, instead, such acts from their side repells me from actively reporting bugs that i can use for much benefit to myself, if they care only about their benefits not the players' favor then I'll do the same too

 

[ELITE JAG]

Mmmmhh... War replays will bring much needed transparency to the game and catch many more cheaters. We've already seen some using 8 and more planes, about 8 Tank Destroyres.... so if the replay is inaccurate, at least it will help Nexon investigate that particular player...

 

[Mountainking]

Catch cheaters, watch in game itself traps positioning, defensive buildings damage (can guess uni researches etc), SH troops if any in itself is huge instead of having to rely on an ally posting an SS or a replay when he gets over on WIFI.
Also, you can spot allies half ass attempts (no gens, mercs etc) or poor strategies or opponents good ideas to hit a base etc. This is good as it is for me. Sorry, if it does not work for you Motaz Tarek

 

[Kuroda Kanbei]

every comment you post seems to be about making the game easier for you or something that you are not satisfied with, never balanced with anything positive. If the game is that unsatisfactory for you, suggest you delete the app.

 

[Motaz Tarek]

cheaters? man what cheaters are u talking about, there are no more cheaters who use a single demolition bug or 50 tank in attacks but anyway I didn't say it's completely useless i said i want a better informative replay system, most of the battles in my war was ill recorded and led to different results than actual ones which is very frustrating when u try to watch to know what weak points u have to correct about ur base

 

[Motaz Tarek]

so what should i do on the forums? come applaud for pay2win and the bugs this game full of? not my problem u see my critics only on the forums, i had many good comments specially when i see something getting fixed, if u don't like critics don't open my posts just as simple as that

 

[Blacknife686]

What would we rather have? NO replays and everyone complaining and slagging Nexon for ignoring the community, or adding SOMETHING even in beta to see if it could work in the future. I for one am hoping they're at least making the effort to add the feature in the first place when they had no obligation to do it at all. May not be as accurate as everyone wants, but in our last war the replays we're accurate for 95% of attacks on both sides, so not everyone is effected by this.

 

[dannemare]

It has nothing to do with some being affected and others not. So-called replays are not actual replays. End of story. Sometimes (often) the AI behaves the same when you execute a replay (which is actually a new battle that only shares with the original battle when and where you touched the screen to deploy or rally), other times it behaves differently. It has zero to do with some being affected and others not.

 

[Xenno]

I personaly hate the war replay sharing. It give away your traps. What troops you have in your strong holds and town center. I do not care if they share it after the war nobody is going to rember Dick from Jane, even if you remember going up against this same team before