big thumbs down for WW replay

[LordJestix]

I personaly hate the war replay sharing. It give away your traps. What troops you have in your strong holds and town center. I do not care if they share it after the war nobody is going to rember **** from Jane, even if you remember going up against this same team before

A good alliance will communicate the location and troop types if they dont five star you, so someone else can 5 star you.

 

[Motaz Tarek]

am not against the step of adding WW replays infact am one of who demanded adding it when past times had many cheaters in attacks and bug abusers
but i stressed that these replays shouldn't be as MP replays which are faulty and increasing of inaccuracies if base designs become more tricky as AI behaviour becomes more likely to change

i for myself both attacks i excuted and recieved in previous war showed WRONG replay which was very frustrating to me and my teammates

I don't want u or anyone else to get me wrong, but the long waiting time for this feature should have been to perfect it and make it as much useful to us as possible

 

[Motaz Tarek]

most of the teams share screenshots of traps and troops with each other nowadays so either way ur base design will be exposed, try having 3 strong designs and switch between them if it happens and u get matched with same alliance again also having a fake design in planning day and switching it before war day starts help in distraction and change of plans to ur opponents, good luck

 

[Xenno]

Yes a good alliance can share all that information in chat or even screen shot the set up. But that take cordination and and builds teamwork. Being able to watch what come out of the strong hold and town center is completely different from your average player who say along the line of " well he got some troops in his stronghold and I was not paying attention to what they were". And as for screen shots unless that screen shot us taken at just the right moment the only info your going to get is setup and maybe some of the traps or just the traps if taken after you 4* Somebody, but miss the QV.

 

[Dimun]

So you're saying Xenno casual players shouldn't have access to the same information as organized teams? Good god, maybe we should remove replays altogether.

 

[Manifesto]

I think the ones complaining must be the only ones with a totally brilliant strategy for warring, one that is so unique no-one has hs come up with it, why else would they complain?

 

[Xenno]

Those organized teams work hard to cordinate and comunicate. Instant war replay sharing reduces the need for cordination and communication. I am not against replay. That help YOU improve. Watching how people attack YOU let YOU know what areas YOU need to improve upon. I use replay to desighn my current base. I got it from somebody else and have since made modification too it using information that I gathered from watching others attack me. I am simply against war replay sharing. You learn nothing except how to beat this other person better at no cost to you, with minimal effort on your part. So the short answer is yes if your not willing to work for the information, then you should not have it.

 

[Xenno]

Also why Dimun do you think that as a casual player you do not have access to the same info. If you want said information, you should discuss that with your guild and work for it

 

[Xenno]

If anybody can come up 1 good way that replay sharing is good and help you improve outside of wars. I will completely change my position that replay sharing complete useless

 

[Mountainking]

Xenno How about you tell us why replay sharing is bad?

 

[LordJestix]

Xenno How about you tell us why replay sharing is bad?

because he has the most insane attack strategy that no one has thought of and he doesnt want anyone to know about it.

 

[Xenno]

Because replay sharing does not help you improve. It give away weaknesses in other people base to you. I used replay to look at how other people attack me. I then use this information to make changes to my base. These changes help me be stronger and more competitive player. War replay sharing give away the weaknesses in your base to the guy we are attacking. Information that would not be deamed important enough to convey by normal chat or clear enough from a snap shot. I watch a friend's atomic bases get 5* this last war. 1st time I have seen it done. He was attack by gpa and this guy did not go for any stars. Did not use a single tactic Just dropped a 100 foot soldiers. And summoned them to the middle of his map.they did not make the entire trip in, but in doing so he revealed that the easy path straight to the tc was not lined neck deep in traps like the bluff intended. He was then later attacked by another atomic and 5*. This atomic went right up mainstreet for the kill. Unless that atomic was incredible stupid or just did not care. Both I think unlikely. I watched both battles and could not figuer out why that gpa would attack somebody that way. Then the sec attack and two & two went together. Several other people were hit the same way. This is the new method of sandbagging. Attack with a lower age to reveal traps, troop donation, and any weaknesses in the base that can be exploited. I realize a bit long winded but hopefully that answer your question. If you had read earlier in the post above. I stated as such before.

 

[yemen]

Multiple people in our alliance could use some improvement in their planning and troop mix. We were able to give them useful and relevant advice based on watching their replays, and hadn't known exactly what to tell them without seeing the replays. So a big help to us, very positive for lower players.

It is also educational and a lot of fun to watch the top guys attack.

 

[Manifesto]

Xenno , you saw this suicide attack only in your last war?!
Does Nexon know about this tactic? Do other alliances know this tactic?
OMG, this could totally change how people go to war against other alliances!!

 

[Xenno]

Right because I care that people know I use 6 morters, 1 wall sapper, 2 wagons, 40 archers and 25 foot solders. 4 bricks of c4 and a sabotage

 

[Xenno]

That does sound interesting. Being abel to watch how your friend got attacked. There might be a bit of educational and entertainment purpose there. Do I think you should be able to veiw your buddies attacks during the war; no. You have a full 24 hrs to look at the bases and stragegise. Do some of us change our base at last moment to keep opponents on their toes; yes. That's part of strateging. If they wanted to do a full recap and do war replay sharing after the war is over I would not have a single issue with it.