Layout Feedback Thread!

[Voxxy5920]

Updated my base design . So i took some advices and spreaded my resources into chambers . But now my garrisons are outside of the walls, so i dont know if this set up is better . Hope you guys can give me some ideas on it

Additionally, i created a ( sort of similar ) base design with some changes . Can you guys tell me which one is better, and what should i improve ? Thanks alot

 

[BoGanora]

No Title

Feedback welcome on my MA layout. So far I've successfully defended my resources against 4 attacks (one was a GA player). I don't give a whip about medals, obviously.

Any ideas to make it better?

 

[Magnifico]

In general I like the first base better because each resource building is in a separate compartment.

1. Move things like that catapult outside your walls while your are upgrading them and swap in a defensive building that's working.
2. No need for gates from the outside into the two compartments with the tower and mill in the first base. A gate to the central compartment might make sense so defenders from your stable could get in if raiders breach the outer wall.
3. I see why you have all your strongest defenses in the central compartment, but that means somebody with a Sabotage war tactic could shut them all down at once. You might want to think about spreading the catapults out so even if attackers shut down or take out one they will still take fire from the other.

 

[Voxxy5920]

Thanks for your suggestions, really appericiate it . I will try to split my catapults and move some gates to improve my base's defense

 

[Voxxy5920]

Just edited my base, looking forward to having some feedbacks . This base defended my resorces from many MA guys . Many of them have only got 50% when attacking me with a huge MA army and buffs . Don't know if that's good, but at least i don't get total a**-kicked

 

[Parmenion]

Totally forgot about this thread. That is looking very good for CA. Well done!

 

[Voxxy5920]

Thanks a lot

 

[KingDarBoja]

Looks pretty good!! Still i am worried about where you placed the traps...

 

[Voxxy5920]

well i usually watch the replay when i get attacked . Then i figure out where the enemies' armies usually march, then i place traps there

 

[KingDarBoja]

No Title

First of all, i would like to show my Early EA base layout which tries to protect town center while splitting aleast the storage buildings of one resource (in this photo, Gold!!).

I would like to know another base layout that improves aleast a good defense against loot raiders x.x cuz everything cost a lot!

Also bonus road is 430% (including the research +10%).

 

[Voxxy5920]

I have not yet reached the EA but i think players with good strategies can easily breach your walls and get your TC, since it is right next to the outer walls
I would switch the TC with the castle IMO

 

[KingDarBoja]

No Title

New base layout (following a design that i saw in these post). Bonus Road is 360% (not sure, forgot to check it). And so far no ones comes for my resources, only for TC (yep, i lost some medals but nothing i can recover).

 

[Crimsondragonfly]

Solid base design for resource protection.

 

[Crimsondragonfly]

You're wasting 3 walls by the stable near the water so I would redesign it so you can use those walls--might be able to fit another building within the walls

 

[KingDarBoja]

I know, but it is hard to fit everything without making it a mess, anyway this layout has worked pretty good against raiders (until a IA player came a destroyed it).

 

[Voxxy5920]

Why would you make 2 layers of walls for your resources ? Wall miners can still destroy your walls in 1 hit . I suggest you use walls to protect your defense also. Because no matter how tough your storages are, they are defenseless when you have no defensive buildings left .

 

[Parmenion]

Here is the layout I'm currently using for my 2nd account in GA:

 

[Emperor Lethal]

No Title

Hey All,

I am new to the forums but I love playing DomiNations.

Would love for anyone to check out my layout and let me know their opinions on what I can approve to make my town as strong as it can be.

Thanks!

 

[aquawind]

No Title

Have been developing my main base based on the base created in the very beginning(which was designed to protect both the resources and town center as much as possible; and also to link as much buildings/structures to the town center to take advantage of the bonus health for the town center and more gold to be collect from the roads), constantly building, upgrading and researching as the they become available and as resources(ie gold, foods and citizens) permits. And I ended up with a such a base(attached screenshot).
Although I'm able to loot large in battles when attacking, I'm constantly being defeated when defending with opponents getting 3 to 5 stars and much, if not all, of the resources available to be looted.
I have tried to modified the layout of it and even to do a complete revamp, designing a new base from scratch in reference to other stronger bases I have met when attacking others. However, the modified bases and the redesigned/rebuilt bases doesn't seems to defend any much better, if not worse.
Would be good if given some advice to improve my base or some guidelines and examples to building a new base, if advised to.

 

[the conqueror]

No Title