World War Replays - Beta Test (6/13 - 6/27)

[Master Contrail Program]

True. Barrage is fine up until EA, then it falls off a lot despite the icon changing from arrows to artillery shells.

First Aid? May as well be lemonade, for all the good it does.

 

[Brutus0304]

Android & iOS are seeing different replays. In an ongoing war, one of our attack on the enemy is showing 5 stars in the results tab. But replay is showing only 4 stars on Android phones but 5 stars on iOS phones. Android replay timer is incorrect. Eg: I am on Android & here is the replay as I see it: https://youtu.be/cU8_F9lByAo. (I fast forwarded the replay a bit to reduce the video size/time). At the start of the video, you can see the results tab showing 5 stars for #6 Rastlin's hit on enemy #8.

 

[Jakkedup1]

Replays during war reveal location of traps. Replays should not be available during war. Either that, or remove traps from the game completely.

 

[Longbow1]

We are really liking these war replays. It lets the more experienced players review and coach the less experienced guys on their attacks and how to improve. However, the downside to this is that by allowing everybody to view everybody elses attacks, it allows your opponents to preview earlier attacks on your base, see where all your traps are, and then makes their follow-up attacks easier. For that reason we believe that war replays should be limited to only being viewable by the attacker and defender of the attack.

 

[LordJestix]

Master Contrail Program commented
Yesterday, 03:04 PM
True. Barrage is fine up until EA, then it falls off a lot despite the icon changing from arrows to artillery shells.

First Aid? May as well be lemonade, for all the good it does.

I feel to make First aid worth anything, it needs to basically cover the entire map when deployed and heal at a much faster rate.

 

[MikeLviv]

Hi everyone about reply in W.W this bad idea!
1. For two days we have replay W.W my alliance have already 2 new players ) because this guys can't make 5* in W.W. and do some mistake wene did attack everybody can see how you do attack and people start screaming him bold alliance can see and this to bad for all people.
2. Some times people fight me 3,4 times in W.W. and take 3,4* and this is good for me and my alliance.Now my base every body can see! How some one attack me so this no more safety And this no good!
3. Nexon if we be have replays in W.W. you will lost players for 100% not now soon you will see.
4. Players will be left his alliance for pressure someone was screaming at him way you attack here not here For all alliance different people some people play for fun some people not
Thank you .

 

[SirViper]

First few wars my replays seemed to be an exact match. This war, the replay shows me getting 4 stars and having a bunch of buildings left when time runs out. In reality, I got 5 stars with over a minute left on the timer. So still some kinks to work out for sure!

 

[Manifesto]

How many times did you watch the replay? Pvp replays average out the more times you watch them.

 

[KatZA]

Would love to provide feedback but we haven't been able to get a war match since you launched the test.

 

[Motaz Tarek]

war replay bug

watching a replay that ended up without destroying all defensive buildings can cause to wipe all ur army including mercs as if u were the attacker
Nb4powerup reported CS and reporting on forums too

 

[Thebigtfish]

I do like the war replays. But they should only be available after the war is complete. It exposes your traps and makes it harder to defend against multiple attacks.

 

[vphucdinh]

World war replay is good. I like it. But It not show correct result war. In notice board, it show 5 star, but when replay, it show 4 star. World war replay, it should be improved. And I thinks, it will be better if replay war was be appeared when the world war is end.

 

[GailWho]

I do like the replays even if it's to watch alliance #16 whoop us. Sure would be great if we could get a fair match.

 

[Michele Nx]

I'd love to participate in the replay beta... but the last war we had ended just after beta started. I was able to record the replay of one of my two attacks, and compared it to the video recording I had happened to make while doing my attack. They lined up! It was a lovely thing.
TinSoldier next time there is a beta period, it would be great if everyone could participate... and maybe glory shouldn't be affected if it's going to result in such chaos as we have had this time.

 

[jmac99]

War Replay and extra planes

Anyone notice extra planes showing up during the war replay? My opponent had 4, I shot down 3 of them and then 3 more showed up with 2 at full health and 1 damaged as it should be. They were Global age Romans, level 189, so that many planes would be excessive I believe

 

[vincentdang4]

I really like the idea of war replays, but my alliance can't get a war match so this feature has not materialized for me

 

[dannemare]

Anyone notice extra planes showing up during the war replay? My opponent had 4, I shot down 3 of them and then 3 more showed up with 2 at full health and 1 damaged as it should be. They were Global age Romans, level 189, so that many planes would be excessive I believe

It's normal. Replays are not replays. The only thing replicated from the original battle is when and where you touched your screen to deploy something or to rally. This means that the "replay" battle likely unfolds a bit different than the original battle, including planes. In other words: the planes survived longer in the original battle, so the attacker was able to send them all into the battlefield again. In the "replay" battle you witnessed they got shot down, but then the "replay" still has to honour the deploys of the original battle and new planes magically appear out of thin air to honour where and when the planes were deployed during the original battle.

 

[TinSoldier]

Great feedback. Thank you!

 

[Ravenstyx]

how could you not like this? I mean it's a way to use the replay as a tool to improve your base against the attacks. before hand you were fighting blind anticipating only would they were going to attack but never knowing where they were actually hitting you that's kind of ridiculous. it's nice to have replaced to know where improvements need to be made it's about time to implement replays as a means to actual smarter Base building and attacking

 

[Durgesh]

It's really great to finally have war replays here. I mean nothing could be better than this. This would reduce cheating and any other dishonest practices. Well done BHG.
That said, for the greater interest of the game/gamers/competitive quotient/developer's interest, it would be a masterstroke if the replays are produced after the war is over.
Reason: #1. Revealing traps on my base makes it vulnerable. Takes away the need for traps
#2. I would not upgrade traps any more if they become visible to all (dev interest)
#3. Why would I need traps, if I know 2attacks would reveal all my traps n 3rd attack will kill my base!??? (All the above interests)
Requesting game developer's to ponder and/or consider this loophole.

Best,
Durgesh
LEGENDS